CourtRecords.org
  • News
  • States
  • Courthouses
  • Forms
  • Login
  1. Court Records
  2. Famous Court Cases
  3. Roth v. United States

Roth v. United States

The U.S. Supreme Court case, Roth v. United States, established the standard for obscenity in printed material as that which would corrupt those whose minds are open to it. The 6-3 decision established a new test for determining what can be classified as obscene.

The First Amendment of the Constitution does not protect obscene material as free speech, the Court decided in this case.

Roth v. United States

Background

Roth, the publisher of an erotic literary periodical from New York, and Alberts, who had a California mail-order business of erotic nude photos, were both charged with violation of state laws that relied on standards set in England in 1868 by the case Regina v. Hicklin. That case determined that Hicklin’s publications were not gratuitously obscene but rather contained obscene material in order to prove a point. In the United States, the Hicklin Rule (based on the court case) gave rise to Comstock Laws in the 1870s which forbade the publishing and dissemination (specifically shipping through the mail) of obscene material as well as material pertaining to birth control.

The Roth case caused the Supreme Court to establish a more modern definition of obscenity that included applying social standards to determine if the publication or image had any redeeming social value. This standard was applied by the following guidelines: appealing to prurient interests, having no socially redeeming value, and being patently offensive.

Following the Roth decision, the 1966 case Memoirs v. Massachusetts further tested the Roth rule. The publication in question during Memoirs was a 1749 book called Fanny Hill which cleared one of the three guidelines but could not be classified as absent of all socially redeeming value (unless it were marketed strictly for its obscene content).

The 1973 case Miller v. California clarified the court’s standard by establishing the SLAP test for obscenity: Serious, Literary, Artistic, Political, or Scientific value.

 

Popular Pages

  • Comprehensive Guide to US Courts and Court Records
  • How to Obtain Divorce Certificates?
  • How to Obtain Court Records?
  • A Non-Disclosure Agreement: the Secret to Keeping Secrets
  • How to File for Bankruptcy?
  • How to Get your Record Expunged
  • Types of Court Cases
  • How to Obtain Birth Certificates?
  • How to Appeal the Court’s Decision?
  • How to Obtain Marriage Licenses and Certificates?
  • Home
  • Login
  • How To
  • Knowledgebase
  • Famous Court Cases
  • Resources
  • News
  • Courthouse Locator
  • Court Forms
  • Terms
  • Privacy
  • Opt Out
  • State Court Records
  • Contact
© Copyright 2019 CourtRecords.org. All Rights Reserved.

CourtRecords.org is not a "consumer reporting agency" as defined by Fair Credit Reporting Act. Our Terms of Service prohibit the use of CourtRecords.org to determine an individual's eligibility for personal credit or employment, tenant screening, or other business transactions, or for any unlawful purposes such as stalking or harassing others. Such use of CourtRecords.org may subject you to civil and criminal litigation and penalties.

Your use of CourtRecords.org is conditioned on your full compliance with our Terms of Service and Privacy Policy.